互动详情

详情日志

解码日志

VoteCast

0x6f...223d

签名

VoteCast(addressindexedvoter,uint256proposalId,uint8support,uint256weight,stringreason)

voter

address

0x65a3870f48b5237f27f674ec42ea1e017e111d63

proposalId

uint256

0x24c

support

uint8

0x0

weight

uint256

0x1

reason

string

My feedback is the same as v1, reposting: The challenging thing about charity type props is that even successful ones will struggle to become self-sustaining. There isn't a path to financial self-sustainability -- the whole operation works through donations like donation we'd be giving through this very proposal. The whole end-game of nouns (in my opinion) is for nouns to be the pinnacle of excellence in certain verticals. It's possible that "charity" could be such a vertical -- maybe nouns is known as one of the great non-profits. But how do we get there? Imo scattering funding to various props makes it challenging for nouns to build up a "brand" around philanthropic work. In order for someone to come and see how much good nouns has done, they'd have to dig through the proposals and see which ones were philanthropic. This added friction makes it challenging for nouns to build up brand. Here's what I think would be great: as an org, we allocate some % of the treasury to philanthropy. We do this under an arm like "nouns philanthropy" or something that can build it's own brand independent of the larger nouns name. Then, we take from the vrbs dao playbook and set up a grants based stream where different orgs can apply to be listed as an initiative. Token holders can vote on how we should split the philanthropy budget and funding will be streamed to various orgs. This solves the sustainability problem -- as long as we pass an annual proposal to fund the philanthropy arm orgs can continue to sustain themselves as they do good. It also solves the branding problem, because all of nouns philanthropic work is done under one arm that can independently build it's brand and be known for doing good. I've been skeptical of charity type proposals in the past and since the ask is quite big here my feeling is the same. However, I think nouns shelter is doing good work and if we had some sort of stream based grants program with a % of the treasury budget allocated to philanthropy I would be happy to vote for giving some of that stream to nouns shelter. TL:DR -- I still think 150K is a big ask, and would like to see all philanthropy type proposals operate under the streaming infra vrbs teams will be building from prop 582

数据

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

686

0x6f...223d

0x651cc9d78606507fdcfc4f37ec37a744d612b1d8f5a73564190577c4f0edb0b6

0x00000000000000000000000065a3870f48b5237f27f674ec42ea1e017e111d63

0x000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000024c

0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000003

687

0x6f...223d

0xfabef36fd46c4c3a6ad676521be5367a4dfdbf3faa68d8e826003b1752d68f4f

0x00000000000000000000000065a3870f48b5237f27f674ec42ea1e017e111d63

数据

0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000c36b389dd75e0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001